Thread Tools
Old January 13, 2003, 20:27   #1
Oerdin
Deity
 
Oerdin's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: In a bamboo forest hiding from Dale.
Posts: 17,436
Is torture ever justified?
Here's an article from this weeks issue of The Economist. Please read and Discuss:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fighting terrorism

Is torture ever justified?

Jan 9th 2003
From The Economist print edition


Even faced with monstrous terrorism, democracies break the taboo at their peril






HOW can democratic governments best fight an enemy like al-Qaeda, whose operatives are encouraged to outdo each other in the barbarity of their attacks? In ways that uphold the values democracies stand for, is the answer one would like to give. Yet faced with the sort of threat al-Qaeda poses, this line is not always so easy to draw.

Western democracies have long upheld the international ban on torture, and have publicly criticised other governments that violate it. The Bush administration has lambasted the Iraqi regime for torturing its opponents and has issued reports about similar abuses in other countries. But in its efforts to defeat al-Qaeda, is the American government itself now quietly sanctioning the use of some forms of torture?



Ends and means
A detailed account of American interrogation methods appeared recently in the Washington Post. The article quoted American officials who describe beatings and the withholding of medical treatment, as well as “stress and duress” techniques, such as sleep deprivation, hooding, and forcing prisoners to hold awkward positions for hours. The officials also say they sent alleged terrorists and lists of questions to countries known for far harsher interrogation techniques.

Although well documented, the account has produced official denials and only a desultory discussion among American commentators, who seem no keener to discuss the subject than the British and French were when the issue arose in Northern Ireland and Algiers. This is understandable. But to evade the question is hypocritical and irresponsible. By speaking anonymously about their interrogation methods, the officials seem to be asking for help: how far should they go in trying to elicit information to stave off another large-scale terrorist attack? They deserve an answer.

One of the few commentators brave enough to take this question seriously has been Alan Dershowitz, a leading American criminal-defence lawyer. He poses the “ticking-bomb” scenario. Suppose you know that there is a bomb about to go off which could claim thousands of victims. You have good reason to believe that a prisoner knows where it is, and that torture may force him to tell. Would you allow him to be tortured? Most people, however reluctantly, answer “yes”.

After September 11th, this is no longer just a theoretical prospect. This week in London, anti-terrorist police arrested a group of men, possibly members or supporters of al-Qaeda, who had apparently been manufacturing ricin, a deadly toxin. If that is so, the authorities will want to know how much was made, where it now is, and who else was involved. Possibly, lives will depend on finding the answers. In circumstances such as those, one can readily imagine intelligence officers quietly saying, “If only we could really lean on these people.”

Mr Dershowitz argues that the new threats do justify a limited use of non-lethal torture in extreme cases, and proposes that judges be able to issue “torture warrants”. His solution is the wrong one. But he is right that the threat of more catastrophic terrorist attacks creates genuine dilemmas.

A first point is that the “ticking-bomb” scenario is not as clarifying as one would wish. If torture is to be allowed, then how much cruelty would be permitted? Would threats against the prisoner's family be all right? His neighbours? His country? Even the extreme circumstance of a “ticking-bomb” threat offers no clear guidance to how far you might go.

But the bigger problem is with Mr Dershowitz's solution. Even if you allow, as many will not, that torture might be justified under the most extreme circumstances, it would be difficult to confine its use to those very rare cases. Any system that allowed torture in tightly controlled situations would risk eroding into wider use. To legalise is to encourage. Israel tried to limit use of physical coercion to extreme cases, but its security forces have ended up using such methods far more widely than was initially foreseen.

If America were to sanction torture, to begin with in extremely rare cases, there might be some immediate gains in security. Much as one would like to believe that torture never succeeds in extracting vital information, history says otherwise. But, for the democratic West, any such gains would be outweighed by greater harm. The prohibition against torture expresses one of the West's most powerful taboos—and some taboos (like that against the use of nuclear weapons) are worth preserving even at heavy cost. Though many authoritarian regimes use torture, not one of even these openly admits it. A decision by the United States to employ some forms of torture, no matter how limited the circumstances, would shatter the taboo. The morale of the West in what may be a long war against terrorism would be gravely set back: to stay strong, the liberal democracies need to be certain that they are better than their enemies.

George Bush has said that the fight against al-Qaeda is a battle for hearts and minds, not just a matter of military power. Though critics focus on his sabre-rattling, Mr Bush has been consistent in his claims to be defending human rights and democracy, and he has persisted in reaching out to Muslims, though he rarely gets credit for this. To keep the moral high ground, he needs to bolster public disavowals of torture by specifying the methods American interrogators can employ, by enforcing the limits, and by desisting from handing prisoners over to less scrupulous allies.


Choosing sides
There is room for discussion about what the limits should be. Given the gravity of the terrorist threat, vigorous questioning short of torture—prolonged interrogations, mild sleep deprivation, perhaps the use of truth serum—might be justified in some cases. Such tactics have ambiguous standing in international law. Some are occasionally employed against ordinary criminals. But there is a line which democracies cross at their peril: threatening or inflicting actual bodily harm. On one side of that line stand societies sure of their civilised values. That is the side America and its allies must choose.
__________________
Christianity is the belief in a cosmic Jewish zombie who can give us eternal life if we symbolically eat his flesh and blood and telepathically tell him that we accept him as our lord and master so he can remove an evil force present in all humanity because a woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from an apple tree.
Oerdin is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 20:32   #2
John-SJ
Alpha Centauri PBEMCivilization II Succession Games
Emperor
 
John-SJ's Avatar
 
Local Time: 06:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Aug 1999
Location: Silicon Valley, USA
Posts: 3,171
Huh!
Is this Civ 3 General, or is it Off Topic? I'm so confused...

John-SJ
John-SJ is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 20:41   #3
SMIFFGIG
Call to Power II Democracy GameCall to Power II MultiplayerCTP2 Source Code Project
Prince
 
SMIFFGIG's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Great Britain
Posts: 684
hehe Oerdin i think you got the wrong forum mate lol
__________________
Oxygen should be considered a drug
Tiberian Sun Retro
My Mod for Tiberian Sun Webmaster of
http://www.tiberiumsun.com
SMIFFGIG is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 20:49   #4
Oerdin
Deity
 
Oerdin's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: In a bamboo forest hiding from Dale.
Posts: 17,436
Opps, this was supposed to be Ot. Can I get a moderator to move this please?
__________________
Christianity is the belief in a cosmic Jewish zombie who can give us eternal life if we symbolically eat his flesh and blood and telepathically tell him that we accept him as our lord and master so he can remove an evil force present in all humanity because a woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from an apple tree.
Oerdin is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 20:51   #5
Oerdin
Deity
 
Oerdin's Avatar
 
Local Time: 07:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: In a bamboo forest hiding from Dale.
Posts: 17,436
I had two different windows of Apolyton open; one looking at the OT and another looking at Civ3-General. I accidently posted this message to the wrong window.
__________________
Christianity is the belief in a cosmic Jewish zombie who can give us eternal life if we symbolically eat his flesh and blood and telepathically tell him that we accept him as our lord and master so he can remove an evil force present in all humanity because a woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from an apple tree.
Oerdin is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 21:01   #6
bobbo008
Prince
 
bobbo008's Avatar
 
Local Time: 08:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: The Wisconsonian Empire
Posts: 635
:O

another American reads The Economist?

and may i add, good choice.
__________________
I use Posturepedic mattresses for a lifetime of temporary relief.
bobbo008 is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 21:08   #7
Cyclotron
Never Ending StoriesThe Courts of Candle'Bre
King
 
Cyclotron's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Cyclo-who?
Posts: 2,995
Or, it was a clever plot to increase Oerdin's postcount...
__________________
Lime roots and treachery!
"Eventually you're left with a bunch of unmemorable posters like Cyclotron, pretending that they actually know anything about who they're debating pointless crap with." - Drake Tungsten
Cyclotron is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 21:46   #8
Underseer
Warlord
 
Underseer's Avatar
 
Local Time: 08:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: in the general vicinity of Chicago
Posts: 146
Bah. I'm entirely too lazy to read that whole article. Besides, I have a short attention sp… oh look, a pencil!

Anyway, torture is only a good idea when bad information is better than no information… which is to say that it's almost never a good idea.
__________________
"It's great to be known, but it's even better to be known as strange." --Takeshi Kaga
Underseer is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 22:34   #9
Dauphin
Civilization IV PBEMPolyCast Team
Deity
 
Dauphin's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Seouenaca, Cantium
Posts: 12,426
Quote:
I had two different windows of Apolyton open; one looking at the OT and another looking at Civ3-General. I accidently posted this message to the wrong window.


Opps, this was supposed to be Ot. Can I get a moderator to move this please?
A-ha.
__________________
"Everybody knows you never go full retard. You went full retard man. Never go full retard"
Dauphin is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 22:56   #10
Kingof the Apes
Civilization III Democracy Game
Prince
 
Kingof the Apes's Avatar
 
Local Time: 06:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Call me KOTA
Posts: 365


Anyway, torture should be more clearly defined, IMO. Does sleep deprivation fall in the same category as administering electric shocks?
__________________
I'm going to rub some stakes on my face and pour beer on my chest while I listen Guns'nRoses welcome to the jungle and watch porno. Lesbian porno.
Supercitzen Pekka
Kingof the Apes is offline  
Old January 13, 2003, 23:49   #11
arslankhan
Chieftain
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally posted by Underseer
Anyway, torture is only a good idea when bad information is better than no information… which is to say that it's almost never a good idea.
I hear that alot, how you only get bad information from torture, but I dont get it. If someone clamped electrodes to my nipples and had their hand on the power switch, you can bet your ass I'd tell them anything they wanted to know!
arslankhan is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 00:37   #12
Nubclear
NationStatesCall to Power II Democracy GameInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamRise of Nations MultiplayerACDG The Human HiveNever Ending StoriesACDG The Free DronesACDG The Cybernetic ConsciousnessGalCiv Apolyton EmpireACDG3 SpartansC4DG Team Alpha CentauriansCiv4 SP Democracy GameDiplomacyAlpha Centauri PBEMCivilization IV PBEMAlpha Centauri Democracy GameACDG Peace
PolyCast Thread Necromancer
 
Nubclear's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: We are all Asher now.
Posts: 1,437
Torture is a human rights violation. So no.

(An interesting fact: The spam viking posts asking if torture is justified in Civ3 General.....)
Nubclear is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 00:53   #13
DuncanK
Warlord
 
DuncanK's Avatar
 
Local Time: 06:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Evil Empire
Posts: 109
What if the person doesn't know anything or is innocent. Torture... No way! That's way over the line.
__________________
"When you ride alone, you ride with Bin Ladin"-Bill Maher
"All capital is dripping with blood."-Karl Marx
"Of course, my response to your Marx quote is 'So?'"-Imran Siddiqui
DuncanK is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 00:54   #14
Nubclear
NationStatesCall to Power II Democracy GameInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamRise of Nations MultiplayerACDG The Human HiveNever Ending StoriesACDG The Free DronesACDG The Cybernetic ConsciousnessGalCiv Apolyton EmpireACDG3 SpartansC4DG Team Alpha CentauriansCiv4 SP Democracy GameDiplomacyAlpha Centauri PBEMCivilization IV PBEMAlpha Centauri Democracy GameACDG Peace
PolyCast Thread Necromancer
 
Nubclear's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: We are all Asher now.
Posts: 1,437
Quote:
Originally posted by bobbo008


another American reads The Economist?
And another Though for some reason I haven't been getting them as of late....

Also, thank me later
Nubclear is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 01:46   #15
Kingof the Apes
Civilization III Democracy Game
Prince
 
Kingof the Apes's Avatar
 
Local Time: 06:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Call me KOTA
Posts: 365
Will this turn into another "Peace on Earth" ?...
Time will tell, I guess.
__________________
I'm going to rub some stakes on my face and pour beer on my chest while I listen Guns'nRoses welcome to the jungle and watch porno. Lesbian porno.
Supercitzen Pekka
Kingof the Apes is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 01:59   #16
Cyclotron
Never Ending StoriesThe Courts of Candle'Bre
King
 
Cyclotron's Avatar
 
Local Time: 09:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Cyclo-who?
Posts: 2,995
The mods seem to be getting lazy... usually these threads are closed fast.
__________________
Lime roots and treachery!
"Eventually you're left with a bunch of unmemorable posters like Cyclotron, pretending that they actually know anything about who they're debating pointless crap with." - Drake Tungsten
Cyclotron is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 02:28   #17
Pyrodrew
Prince
 
Pyrodrew's Avatar
 
Local Time: 06:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2000
Posts: 679
Quote:
I'm entirely too lazy to read that whole article. Besides, I have a short attention sp… oh look, a pencil!
What kind of pencil?
Pyrodrew is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 05:51   #18
TacticalGrace
Prince
 
TacticalGrace's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Invisible, Silent, Deadly.
Posts: 310
Civilizations in civ I and II employed extreme interrogation techniques in order to discover technologies when an enemy cities was captured. Due to the intervention of the international courts, this practice was discontinued on Civ3.
__________________
Do not be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed...
TacticalGrace is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 06:06   #19
Nubclear
NationStatesCall to Power II Democracy GameInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamRise of Nations MultiplayerACDG The Human HiveNever Ending StoriesACDG The Free DronesACDG The Cybernetic ConsciousnessGalCiv Apolyton EmpireACDG3 SpartansC4DG Team Alpha CentauriansCiv4 SP Democracy GameDiplomacyAlpha Centauri PBEMCivilization IV PBEMAlpha Centauri Democracy GameACDG Peace
PolyCast Thread Necromancer
 
Nubclear's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: We are all Asher now.
Posts: 1,437
Quote:
Originally posted by Pyrodrew


What kind of pencil?
You'll notice that as his post clearly showed, he has gone off too other things
Nubclear is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 06:31   #20
Alex
Emperor
 
Alex's Avatar
 
Local Time: 11:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Mar 1999
Location: Brasil
Posts: 3,958
Quote:
Originally posted by TacticalGrace
Civilizations in civ I and II employed extreme interrogation techniques in order to discover technologies when an enemy cities was captured. Due to the intervention of the international courts, this practice was discontinued on Civ3.
A valuable effort to try and maintain this thread on Civ3-General. Nice try, TG.
__________________
'Yep, I've been drinking again.'
Alex is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 07:32   #21
Kampus majore
Chieftain
 
Kampus majore's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Zoetermeer
Posts: 96
Quote:
Originally posted by cyclotron7
The mods seem to be getting lazy... usually these threads are closed fast.
You can say that again! Are they still on vacation?
Anyway my behaviour in civ3 as a leader of a civ is different from what I would do in real life. But on the other hand the AI civs aren't realistic either....
__________________
It is I Le Clerk! ;-) Quote from Allo allo.
Kampus majore is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 08:05   #22
Hurricane
Warlord
 
Hurricane's Avatar
 
Local Time: 16:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Arctic Hill
Posts: 266
What do you think about pop-rushing? And slave workers? Civ 3 is in fact a very immoral game, IMHO!
Hurricane is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 08:14   #23
bongo
lifer
PtWDG2 Mohammed Al-SahafPtWDG Neu DemogypticaCivilization III PBEMC3CDG Blood Oath HordeIron CiversC4DG The HordeC4WDG éirich tuireann
Emperor
 
bongo's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: MOOHOOHO
Posts: 4,737
At least they don't call them slaves, unlike in ctp where you could have large slave populations.
__________________
Don't eat the yellow snow.
bongo is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 08:39   #24
Deathwalker
Prince
 
Deathwalker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Great Britain
Posts: 671
Shouldn't this be on Of Topic
__________________
I have walked since the dawn of time and were ever I walk, death is sure to follow. As surely as night follows day.
Deathwalker is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 10:21   #25
wilbill
Warlord
 
wilbill's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Not Mayberry, NC
Posts: 140
Modest Proposal For Civ 4

Civilization 3 "Interrogation" Advisor Screen

(Advisor strongly resembles John Ashcroft)

"Sire, we have captured a (insert enemy civ) terrorist cell operating in (insert your cap city). Do you wish to obtain information from them by:"

o Sleep Deprivation - Results in 20 Turns (50 gold)
o Electric Shock - Results in 10 Turns (110 gold)
o Bamboo Shoots Under Fingernails - Results in 5 Turns (175 gold)
o Date with Catherine of Russia - Results in 1 Turn (300 gold)
__________________
"Illegitimi non carborundum"

Last edited by wilbill; January 14, 2003 at 10:29.
wilbill is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 10:33   #26
punkbass2000
Civilization III MultiplayerCivilization III Democracy GameApolyton UniversityCivilization III PBEM
King
 
punkbass2000's Avatar
 
Local Time: 10:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Waterloo, ON, Canada
Posts: 1,500
Wouldn't it be 'The Civilization 4 "Interrogation" Advisor' screen?
__________________
"I used to be a Scotialist, and spent a brief period as a Royalist, but now I'm PC"
-me, discussing my banking history.
punkbass2000 is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 10:39   #27
bongo
lifer
PtWDG2 Mohammed Al-SahafPtWDG Neu DemogypticaCivilization III PBEMC3CDG Blood Oath HordeIron CiversC4DG The HordeC4WDG éirich tuireann
Emperor
 
bongo's Avatar
 
Local Time: 15:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: MOOHOOHO
Posts: 4,737
You may get a reputation hit from that.
__________________
Don't eat the yellow snow.
bongo is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 11:43   #28
Ursa
Settler
 
Ursa's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Washington, D.C.
Posts: 8
Puhleeze! If anything, Bush/Cheney would advocate "preemtive torture" and "forward thumb-screwing."
Ursa is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 11:45   #29
TacticalGrace
Prince
 
TacticalGrace's Avatar
 
Local Time: 14:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Invisible, Silent, Deadly.
Posts: 310
Quote:
Originally posted by Alexnm


A valuable effort to try and maintain this thread on Civ3-General. Nice try, TG.
well you know...

Every thread is sacred
every thread is great
when a thread is wasted
the mod becomes irate.
__________________
Do not be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed...
TacticalGrace is offline  
Old January 14, 2003, 12:25   #30
Master Zen
PtWDG Glory of WarApolytoners Hall of FameInterSite Democracy Game: Apolyton TeamSpanish CiversPtWDG2 Latin LoversC3C IDG: Apolyton TeamC4DG Gathering Storm
Deity
 
Master Zen's Avatar
 
Local Time: 08:32
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: of naughty
Posts: 10,579
Quote:
Originally posted by wilbill
Modest Proposal For Civ 4

Civilization 3 "Interrogation" Advisor Screen

(Advisor strongly resembles John Ashcroft)

"Sire, we have captured a (insert enemy civ) terrorist cell operating in (insert your cap city). Do you wish to obtain information from them by:"

o Sleep Deprivation - Results in 20 Turns (50 gold)
o Electric Shock - Results in 10 Turns (110 gold)
o Bamboo Shoots Under Fingernails - Results in 5 Turns (175 gold)
o Date with Catherine of Russia - Results in 1 Turn (300 gold)
Date with Catherine???? My god, what kind of a savage are you!!
__________________
A true ally stabs you in the front.

Secretary General of the U.N. & IV Emperor of the Glory of War PTWDG | VIII Consul of Apolyton PTW ISDG | GoWman in Stormia CIVDG | Lurker Troll Extraordinaire C3C ISDG Final | V Gran Huevote Team Latin Lover | Webmaster Master Zen Online | CivELO (3°)
Master Zen is offline  
 

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:32.


Design by Vjacheslav Trushkin, color scheme by ColorizeIt!.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Apolyton Civilization Site | Copyright © The Apolyton Team