Thread Tools
Old July 16, 2003, 00:57   #91
Kramerman
Prince
 
Kramerman's Avatar
 
Local Time: 23:43
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: UT, Austin - The live music capital of the world
Posts: 884
Quote:
Originally posted by Ming
Whose to say whether it's necessary or not. Having a standing army available might be considered necessary by some people.

Frankly... I think all young men and women should have a mandatory 1 or 2 year service to their country... whether it's in the military or communty service... It would teach them that freedom doesn't come for free, and that EVERYBODY needs to do their share. Many people have died so that we can enjoy the freedoms that we do have...
I say the exact same thing to my friends... they call me a fascist zionist(?... i guess cause israel does somethn similar). Actually, my idea is a little different, but basically this. You should read Star Ship Troopers (the book is COMPLETELY different from the movie, much more political and philosophical), it goes into detail a government that works kinda like this.
__________________
"I bet Ikarus eats his own spunk..."
- BLACKENED from America's Army: Operations
Kramerman - Creator and Author of The Epic Tale of Navalon in the Civ III Stories Forum
Kramerman is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 00:57   #92
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Quote:
If people aren't willing to defend the nation, why should the nation exist?

Further, the two times the US has been invaded, there have been plenty of volunteers (Revolution, War of 1812).
Yup, is a country really worth fighting for if people won't even volunteer? Nope. When we have been invaded, people did volunteer.

Quote:
I don't count the Civil War, which was really caused by the US anyway.
Interesting how both sides used a draft to wage that war, huh?
Kind of exposes the nature of drafts...
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 00:57   #93
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
Whether you like it or not... the constitution does allow the government to pass laws. And while the government would never pass a law saying you have to wear a pink tutu... it can pass laws that say you must pay taxes or can be conscripted.
Certainly the Constitution allows Congress to pass laws, but even Imran will agree that the Constitution doesn't allow the government to pass *any* law.

Quote:
Yes... and the current laws have been deemed ok according to the constitution... your point?
Various laws throughout US history have been deemed OK by SCOTUS, when clearly they are wrong.

Quote:
And as far as moral goes... again, only YOUR opinion, so that doesn't make it a fact... just your opinion.
Are you a moral relativist, or do you believe in certain absolutes? Serious question.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 00:58   #94
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
Interesting how both sides used a draft to wage that war, huh?
Kind of exposes the nature of drafts...
Yes, and I'll also point out that just because I say the US was at fault in causing the Civil War doesn't mean I think the CSA was behaving very morally, either.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 00:58   #95
Kramerman
Prince
 
Kramerman's Avatar
 
Local Time: 23:43
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: UT, Austin - The live music capital of the world
Posts: 884
Quote:
Are you a moral relativist, or do you believe in certain absolutes? Serious question.
If he is a moral relativist, hes not when it comes to the rules of this site (i would know).

despite your culture, the rules are rules
__________________
"I bet Ikarus eats his own spunk..."
- BLACKENED from America's Army: Operations
Kramerman - Creator and Author of The Epic Tale of Navalon in the Civ III Stories Forum
Kramerman is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:00   #96
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
Hes a moral relativist,
I'll let Ming answer. I'm not going to debate Ming's position with anyone other than Ming
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:02   #97
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Btw, I haven't seen anyone refute David's claim that the draft is immoral. People have only argued it is less immoral that the possible consequences...
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:03   #98
Kramerman
Prince
 
Kramerman's Avatar
 
Local Time: 23:43
Local Date: November 1, 2010
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: UT, Austin - The live music capital of the world
Posts: 884
Quote:
Originally posted by David Floyd


I'll let Ming answer. I'm not going to debate Ming's position with anyone other than Ming
yeah, i didnt mean to say that, i edited it and said what i meant to
__________________
"I bet Ikarus eats his own spunk..."
- BLACKENED from America's Army: Operations
Kramerman - Creator and Author of The Epic Tale of Navalon in the Civ III Stories Forum
Kramerman is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:03   #99
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
I believe in certain absolutes when it comes to morality... But conscription doesn't fall on my immoral list

And yes, I don't feel that ANY law can be passed (and that's why your red tutu law is still just a straw man)

But laws that have been passed and are considered constitutional at the time are the law, and must be followed, or you must except the results of ignorning them. Again... if you disagree with a law, fine... but you are expected to follow it... or choose other courses of action... like leaving the country or trying to fight them in legal fashions.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:06   #100
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Quote:
Originally posted by Berzerker
Btw, I haven't seen anyone refute David's claim that the draft is immoral. People have only argued it is less immoral that the possible consequences...
Uhhh... you can't refute personal opinions. I feel it isn't immoral. I give my reasons... and he gave his. He thinks he's right... I think I'm right. again... just opinion, and not facts.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:06   #101
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Quote:
Yes, and I'll also point out that just because I say the US was at fault in causing the Civil War doesn't mean I think the CSA was behaving very morally, either.
True, and there wouldn't have been a war without drafts. But some people think killing off 600,000 people to end slavery was justified. Just how their position would change if it was their family members being killed is another, interesting question.
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:07   #102
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
I believe in certain absolutes when it comes to morality...
Excellent, I agree. What absolutes do you believe in?

Quote:
And yes, I don't feel that ANY law can be passed
Excellent. Presumably, you agree that Congress can't pass a law that is against the Constitution.

Let me ask you this, then. Can a law be unconstitutional, even if SCOTUS says it isn't? Take an extreme example - if Congress passes a law banning the Muslim religion, and SCOTUS allows it, is it really Constitutional?

Quote:
But laws that have been passed and are considered constitutional at the time are the law, and must be followed,
What about laws that violate a moral absolute, which you have agreed exist?
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:08   #103
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
Uhhh... you can't refute personal opinions. I feel it isn't immoral. I give my reasons... and he gave his. He thinks he's right... I think I'm right. again... just opinion, and not facts.
And it'll remain as such until we find out what you believe are moral absolutes.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:12   #104
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
First... this thread is about conscription...

And the Country has had it in the past... and it was deemed constitutional... and it doesn't violate any moral absolute that I have... So your questions are just not relevent to me on this topic.

But as far as absolutes... murder (and I don't consider self defense murder) rape... slavery (and I don't consider conscription slavery)... racism... just a few off the top of my head.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:13   #105
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Quote:
Uhhh... you can't refute personal opinions. I feel it isn't immoral. I give my reasons... and he gave his. He thinks he's right... I think I'm right. again... just opinion, and not facts.
So, at the risk of being uninvited for future golf outings , do you believe it is moral to force others to die for your security?
If someone is trying to murder me, can I morally force you to leave your family and stand guard outside my home?
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:16   #106
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
I believe the first time a draft was enacted was the US Civil War, but I certainly wouldn't point to Abraham Lincoln as a defender of the Constitution.
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:18   #107
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Berz... I always seperate politics from friendship... so no worry on the golf

As to your question... I was in the lottery for the draft for Viet Nam... I didn't get selected, but I would have gone. I would have taken the risk to die for somebody else's security. I have no problem with the youth of today taking the same risk I would have. I don't see it as an issue of being moral or not. It my mind, it's a contract between you and the government.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:22   #108
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
First... this thread is about conscription...
It's about the morality of conscription.

Quote:
And the Country has had it in the past... and it was deemed constitutional...
The original case here is Arver v US. This decision was pretty much made in an era of war fervor, that was made even more evident by a case called Schenk v US. Basically, SCOTUS upheld a number of laws preventing the criticism of war, criticising Conscription, even criticising the government, and rejected a challenge to conscription. Anyone who points to these decisions and claims they are a result of ANYTHING other than nationalism/patriotism and war fervor are basically wrong.

Quote:
But as far as absolutes... murder (and I don't consider self defense murder) rape... slavery (and I don't consider conscription slavery)... racism... just a few off the top of my head.
OK, those are absolutes, and I agree that these are always wrong. Now, WHY are they always wrong? What do they all have in common?

The common denominators are individual liberty, and the right to life, wouldn't you agree?
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:23   #109
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
I would have taken the risk to die for somebody else's security. I have no problem with the youth of today taking the same risk I would have.
If this is true, why didn't you volunteer?
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:26   #110
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Yep... but the difference is, I don't see it as a loss of personal freedom. I see it as a contract between country and citizen. It is a choice you agree to make by being a citizen. If you don't agree, you can change your citizenship to somewhere else... your choice... your individual freedom...
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:27   #111
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
Yep... but the difference is, I don't see it as a loss of personal freedom. I see it as a contract between country and citizen.
And you still haven't justified the existence of such a contract. It certainly didn't exist at the beginning, so where did it come from? Did the government just make it up?

Furthermore, saying that being forced to join the military isn't a loss of personal freedom is ridiculous. It ignores the definition of several words, most notably "force" and "freedom".
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:29   #112
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Quote:
Originally posted by David Floyd
If this is true, why didn't you volunteer?
I took my chance by being in the lottery... I signed up, and didn't get called. I was lucky. And that's the way it was back then. I lived up to my contract with the US government.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:29   #113
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Thank God you lucked out like my older brother. Leaving aside the fact you might have died, for no one's security except possibly for the S Vietnamese, the fact you would have gone doesn't mean forcing you to go would have been moral. I can certainly risk my life to save another person, but that doesn't mean it's moral for me to force you to give up your life. But people don't sign this contract, it's imposed upon them by others, often by people who will avoid the same contract when it's their turn to go.

Quote:
Berz... I always seperate politics from friendship... so no worry on the golf
Whew, you didn't seem like the type to hold a grudge over such mundane matters. But I did see the pleasure you got banning people.
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:30   #114
Ben Kenobi
Civilization II Democracy GameCivilization II Succession GamesCivilization II Multiplayer
Emperor
 
Ben Kenobi's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 18,269
Quote:
It is a choice you agree to make by being a citizen.
Most are born to their citizenship, so how can this be a choice?
__________________
Scouse Git (2) LaFayette and Adam Smith you will be missed
"All my own perception of beauty both in majesty and simplicity is founded upon Our Lady." - JRR Tolkein
Get busy living or get busy dying.
Ben Kenobi is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:30   #115
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
Quote:
I took my chance by being in the lottery... I signed up, and didn't get called. I was lucky. And that's the way it was back then. I lived up to my contract with the US government.
Sure, but if you were so willing to go fight, then you should have volunteered and taken the place of someone not so willing.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:31   #116
David Floyd
Emperor
 
Local Time: 05:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: The bottom of a large bottle of beer
Posts: 4,620
By the way, if anyone thinks that Daniel Webster is an authority on the Constitution, check out this link:

http://www.antiwar.com/paul/paul32.html

Regardless of the URL, it's an actual speech by Webster posted in its entirety, not some analysis of Webster's unstated thoughts.
__________________
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/DaveDaDouche
Read my seldom updated blog where I talk to myself: http://davedadouche.blogspot.com/
David Floyd is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:33   #117
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Quote:
Originally posted by David Floyd
And you still haven't justified the existence of such a contract. It certainly didn't exist at the beginning, so where did it come from? Did the government just make it up?
No... they didn't "make it up"... they passed a LAW. And from that point on, it is a contract. Again... laws have changed since the beginning... and that's life.

Quote:
Furthermore, saying that being forced to join the military isn't a loss of personal freedom is ridiculous. It ignores the definition of several words, most notably "force" and "freedom".
No... it isn't ridiculous. You aren't being FORCED. You have a CHOICE... the FREEDOM TO SAY, I'm not going... and you can face the penality, or leave the country.

Again... as a citizen, you must follow the rules. But you always have the freedom to go someplace where you can find what you are looking for.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:33   #118
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Hey David, when were those cases? Were they during the Civil War or before (or after)?
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:35   #119
Berzerker
Civilization II MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Emperor
 
Berzerker's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: May 1999
Location: topeka, kansas,USA
Posts: 8,164
Quote:
Again... as a citizen, you must follow the rules.
Berzerker is offline  
Old July 16, 2003, 01:37   #120
Ming
lifer
Civilization II MultiplayerCivilization III MultiplayerPolyCast TeamCivilization IV: MultiplayerApolytoners Hall of Fame
Retired
 
Ming's Avatar
 
Local Time: 00:43
Local Date: November 2, 2010
Join Date: Dec 1969
Location: Mingapulco - CST
Posts: 30,317
Quote:
Originally posted by David Floyd
Sure, but if you were so willing to go fight, then you should have volunteered and taken the place of someone not so willing.
I never said I was "willing to fight"... I said I lived up to my commitment to the state. If I had been called, I would have... but I wasn't. I lived up to my contract with the state...

Remember... nothing is forcing you to be a citizen of the US... you have the Freedom to renounce that citizenship if you don't want to live up to what it means by being an American.
__________________
Keep on Civin'
Civ V Civilization V Civ5 CivV Civilization 5 Civ 5 - Do your part!
Ming is offline  
 

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:43.


Design by Vjacheslav Trushkin, color scheme by ColorizeIt!.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Apolyton Civilization Site | Copyright © The Apolyton Team